|
Officially
Released Versions
"What Difference Does It Make?" 7"/12" (RT 146 - Released January,
1984). This John Porter-produced version of the song features the
entire band. It was made widely available on the Louder Than
Bombs compilation in 1987.
Hatful Of Hollow (Rough 76 - Released November, 1984).
This excellent acoustic version was recorded for the John Peel Show and
produced by Roger Pusey. This version features only Morrissey and
Marr, and is a much superior, affecting version of the song.
Bootleg
Versions
Devils Charm (live at the Assembly Room, Derby, December
7, 1983)
Electric Stars, Live At The Electric Ballroom; Live At The Electric Ballroom,
19 December 1983 (live at the Electric Ballroom, December 19, 1983)
Hammersmith, Last of the English Roses, Misery Loves Company (live
at the Hammersmith Palais, March 12, 1984)
Smithsessions (John Peel Show)
Quintessential
Bootleg Version
The live version from the Hammersmith Palais is an excellent
version of this incredibly moving and beautiful early Smiths classic.
The rest of the concert is great too!
Critical
Commentary
"Fiendishly
good." - Bill Black, Sounds, November 17, 1984
"An
affecting little piece where The Smiths' formulaic modal melodies match
neatly with a lyric where, for once, Morrissey isn't trying to be Dorian
Gray." - Adam Sweeting, Melody Maker, 1984
Comtesse
Review (as if you care)
This is one of the most beautiful songs The Smiths ever recorded,
especially the acoustic version with just Morrissey and Marr featured
on Hatful Of Hollow. (Bass and drums are completely unnecessary
to the composition.) The lyrics, among Morrissey's finest, ache with nostalgic
loss. I challenge anyone to listen to this song and not be reminded of
a special someone forever lost to the past. Marr's music is achingly beautiful
- the perfect foil for Morrissey's words. Three minutes and two seconds
of melancholy perfection. Grade: A+
|